Sam and Dean catch a case deep in the wilderness where some fugly has been snatching hikers. Same song, different singer. The boys disagree about what they're hunting, how they should hunt it, whether they should split up -- but when Dean is on the menu, Sam has to prove that he's up for the task.
Chapter One →
Chapter Two →
I also have it on good authority that The Boogeyman, the long casefic written by my partner in crime caladrius75 , is in the home stretch, so do yourselves a favor and get caught up on that asap!